The All Too Real Threat of Consumer Identity Theft and What Mortgage Banks Must Do to Help Prevent It

January 29, 2020

A recent article in Bloomberg Business Week chronicled the SIX YEAR plight of a reporter who was a victim of identity theft.  The cost mentally, physically, financially and to his reputation was severe and life changing.  Consumers are paralyzed without good credit, and the theft of identity can  launch a nightmare scenario involving significant personal losses and restricted access to much needed credit.

Mortgage lenders are obligated through compliance rules as well as state laws to protect consumer non-public information typically collected in the course of the mortgage application, loan approval and closing process so that it does not fall into the wrong hands.  Few truly understand the magnitude of diligence and supervision that is required to effectively protect this sensitive data.  Banks routinely collect nearly all personal and financial data that defines a consumer’s identity and existence while evaluating a mortgage loan application.  This data is handled by many people internally and externally in the course of normal business operations.

To the extent that a lender can manage and control its staff they can effectively, with rules and proper management, prevent losses.  However when lenders deliver some or all of the consumer data to vendors outside their sphere of influence and control the risk rises to a high alert levels.  Does the vendor itself have internal controls?  Are their employees who have access to the data screened and monitored?  How is data stored and protected from intrusion and theft? Does the vendor have sufficient insurance coverage (errors and omissions, crimes and cyber) to offset any potential losses?  These are only some of the critical questions that must be addressed when considering the responsibility a lender has when sharing consumer data.

One of the most serious gaps in managing the risk of consumer data privacy and protection takes place at the closing table. In most instances lenders are sending their money as well as consumer non-public financial and personal information into the hands of people with whom they have a very temporary and superficial relationship. A lender’s ability to assess risk from these transaction partners is too often hampered by the volume of business, lack of trained staff, conflicts where the partners may also be referral sources, and insufficient time to be thorough and analytical in evaluating the level of appropriate risk.

Outsourcing vendor management can be an effective solution provided the vendor assessment company has the tools, technology, process and credibility to assess risk, report on risk and flag issues without causing delays to the loan process or the closing.

Seeking and purchasing insurance is helpful however it is not a deterrent or preventative solution, only a concession that in the event a loss occurs there is a policy limit to offload the financial harm.  By then consumers are outraged, reputations are damaged, and, like the Bloomberg article author it may be years to set things straight.

To learn more about what Secure Insight offers to help manage closing table risk, please visit our website at





Share this post

Recent Posts

February 9, 2023

Why Compliance And Fraud Prevention Are Critical For Mortgage Lenders Right Now

January 25, 2023

NCUA Releases 2023 Guidelines for Credit Unions on Fraud Prevention, Cybersecurity and Consumer Protection

January 17, 2023

Protect Yourself From Fraud

Leave a Reply

                          Privacy Policy